A literary pace and some Salem-witch lore defined "All Fun and Games" which felt like a clichéd but curious campfire fable. I liked how they mentioned some stories being lost along the flow of history. One such loss was alluded to be a curse, passed down through an ensorcelled blade.
The Fletcher family experienced the blade's dark mischief, which later saw Marcus Fletcher (played by Asa Butterfield) committing murder and more. He, Natalia Dyer as Billie Fletcher, Laurel Marsden as Sophie Fletcher, and Benjamin Evan Ainsworth as Jonah Fletcher shone in the movie, which didn't exactly give any of them enough room to stretch their acting tendons. But they boasted great chemistry in every scene they were in.
The folk-tale flair with which the movie progressed made it seem worth watching, though just once. I liked how they built up the demon activity. Even though the plot picked up pace it grew predictable, a fact that removed much of the story's intrigue.
Jonah unwittingly found a strange bone blade and innocently began experimenting with dark witchcraft without fully realizing what he was getting into - rather, losing himself in. What later happened to his older brother Marcus made more sense in retrospect.
The knife essentially held the demon-corrupted soul of Daniel Good (played by Shylo Molina) who 'passed on' from one person to the next by making them It (like the game), which progressed to Hangman (another game), and so on. But the 'devil made me do it' trope has been done to death, so this plot-element soon wore out its welcome.
The historical flashbacks and 'possessed realm' scenes were remarkable. They evoked a 90s vibe and, moreover, weren't mundane. Maclean Fish as the fanatic puritan had good screen presence. But the screenplay barely gave him the time of day, so it was interesting but also disappointing to see sporadic flashes of his original deeds.
The way they minimally showcased supernatural activity was okay. Because not all paranormal dangers in real life are readily visible, let alone describable. The focus soon fell on the ritualistic bone knife, which held plenty of curiosity value. From its whispering blade to its creepy etchings, I liked its design and use in the movie.
The diary of a persecuted woman (Joanna Good, played by Marina Stephenson Kerr) from that era equally captivated. She apparently chronicled her being accused of witchcraft and how they killed her son Daniel as well. She wanted revenge and so, ironically, turned to witchcraft to claim it, starting with making a cursed bone blade using one of Daniel's bones.
The 'games' angle tied up neatly with this lore, but the whole affair felt heavily contrived and overly rushed. Though the family dynamics were on point, the plot itself lacked depth and nuance. It was also far from scary. However, a few eerie elements managed to make the movie passably intriguing.
All in all, "All Fun and Games" did not quite live up to its name, but it stoked my curiosity nevertheless and made me watch it till the end just to see how things would pan out.
